Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

IC Languages #301

Closed
wants to merge 9 commits into from
Closed

Conversation

Hanzdegloker
Copy link

My proposal for IC languages which I have been wishy washy over for like a month tryna workshop.

Before anyone asks yes I know there is another proposal already up about languages, I've been thinking over my own version of this very same concept over for a long while now and seeing someone else beat me to the punch got me in gear to finally finish writing this.

Happy to adjust as need be.

@github-actions github-actions bot added Design Related to design documentation for Space Station 14. English labels Sep 6, 2024
@Everturning
Copy link

this is definitely under baked. the other doc has concepts for what languages would look like to someone who doesn't speak it. this doesn't. but that's besides the point.

| Nar'sian | You know how people sound when they drink Cogchamp? Just that.

Why would they be speaking ratvarian? they're narsie cultists.

| NT Crew | Galactic Common | Sounds like a combination of Mandarin Chinese and various forms of Spanish |
|Humans | Galactic Uncommon | Sounds like a combination of Russian and English |

I don't like this because it might make people confused and ahelp people not speaking English in the English servers and the same for other languages. It should just be randomized characters for each letter.

RD, whom can understand but cannot speak Encoded Audio Language, just to make sure those silicons ain't up to no good...

I think in the future, the binary chip will be removed from RD's locker, and so this would really only benefit the RD if he was standing right next to a borg (assuming they still have the bug where they broadcast their messages over AI in whispers)

Now, I would also like to state mobs such as mice and mothroaches, do not understand galactic common at all. Mothroaches are a little special and can understand moffic, but cannot speak it. Basically majority sentient and non-sentient creatures speak/understand their respective languge and thats it,

👎 👎 👎 . Let them understand common.

overall this seems to be just a worse form of the other doc imo. More tedium, less fun.

@Hanzdegloker
Copy link
Author

I don't like this because it might make people confused and ahelp people not speaking English in the English servers and the same for other languages. It should just be randomized characters for each letter.

I use sound like in the most vague of terms, I assure you it would not be hard to decipher that it's gibberish in game. Something I forgot to touch on in the document actually is that every language having a different font would be great for telling what language someone is speaking at a glance even if you understand it. Full Russian sentences in Galactic common on an EN server should be easy enough to spot.

I think in the future, the binary chip will be removed from RD's locker, and so this would really only benefit the RD if he was standing right next to a borg (assuming they still have the bug where they broadcast their messages over AI in whispers)

I mean, if the binary chip is removed it still makes a neat situational trait. Borgs can still chat between each other in their borg tongue and two emagged borgs could plot something nasty in plain sight, never mind binary

👎 👎 👎 . Let them understand common.

Not opposed to the idea, I already let the round start sentient pets do so. I just found the idea of playing as a mouse getting yelled at in a strange language amusing

overall this seems to be just a worse form of the other doc imo. More tedium, less fun.

Not sure where the tedium comes into play, as for fun I am not against tweaking the understanding common part.

@dffdff2423
Copy link
Contributor

dffdff2423 commented Sep 19, 2024

I am against the concept of humanoid languages because they often lead to metafriending and because ss14 is at it's core a RP game. I think intentionally excluding people from the conversation is not really the best design for ss14. The main use case I can see for languages is insulting people without them being able to understand you- which is quite funny and I am all for. Languages can also provide a bit of character to species, but no more then what can already be done via custom emotes. I personally strongly think that the downsides of humanoid languages outweigh the upsides.

On a more technical side languages should probably depend on a full chat refactor due to the current state of chat code.

@superjj18
Copy link

superjj18 commented Sep 20, 2024

wizden would never allow race specific languages due to their stance on speciesm. Disappointing that all races are essentially stat/ability-swapped humans but it has its community reasons.

@DandiIion
Copy link

I think intentionally excluding people from the conversation is not really the best design for ss14.

This is already thoroughly present in the form of radio channels/departments. Not a fair reason to veto imo.

often lead to metafriending

Having things in common is inevitable and I strongly disagree that it would lead to meta-friending, more like would lead to Incharacter-friending. Don't think its any different from salvage often becoming pals with their lil walkietalkies.
Same hat

@Aisu9
Copy link

Aisu9 commented Oct 5, 2024

Don't think its any different from salvage often becoming

or having a good interaction with a botanist/chemist/doctor/any job and start playing more of this job to be with them, you don't need a departmental communication channel or specie languages to form a group of friend, if you really want ot take on the language use helping forming metafriend groups then it's already actively done by using English as our mean of communication in-game

@LankLTE
Copy link
Contributor

LankLTE commented Oct 5, 2024

While languages do provide some gameplay opportunities, we feel that ultimately the only reason to use a species language is to exclude a group of players, of then those of another species or of another group. Due to our complete ban on speciesism and to prevent issues with metacliques / metafriending, we do not wish to have roundstart species have languages. The system would still be desired for wild animals and such, however. I'll be closing this document as it is entirely based on roundstart species languages, but if you wish to change it feel free to request it to be re-opened.
(Apologies for this being so late, this document had been reviewed some time ago and we merely forgot to post the conclusion).

@LankLTE LankLTE closed this Oct 5, 2024
@LankLTE LankLTE mentioned this pull request Oct 5, 2024
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
Design Related to design documentation for Space Station 14. English
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

7 participants